New Highliner® Pencil Eyeliner

Sale price $24.00

Color: Black

Smooth, define, and shape with precision.

The same sustainable wood pencil you love, now with an optimized formula for a smoother, more precise application. Powered by organic castor oil for a creamier glide and balanced with carnauba and candelilla wax for lasting wear, it delivers rich pigment without pulling or tugging.


Beyond Clean Facts

EWG Verified® • Leaping Bunny Certified • Certified 4ocean Plastic Neutral • Non-GMO • Vegan • Gluten-Free • And So Much More...

Overall rating: 4.7916665 / 5 from 72 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The New Highliner® Pencil Eyeliner offers a sustainable wood pencil with an optimized formula for smooth application. Powered by organic castor oil, it provides a creamy glide and rich pigment without pulling. Customers praise its lasting wear and ease of removal.

Summary topics

  • Color Quality: 21%
  • Formula Effectiveness: 25%

Review topics: ["color","formula","look","lines","shade","eyes","eyeliner","pencil","pigment","glides","highliner","choice"].

Review highlights

  • "I love the brown color, it glides on smoothly making a nice line."Judy Y.
  • "Espresso is my favorite color."Jessica G.
  • "It’s glides on smoothly and has great pigment and color."Ashley G.

Reviews

What an improvement!

"I love the new eyeliner! The old one was so hard to get to actually mark on my eye that it was borderline painful to use. The new one transfers onto my eye so smoothly and easily, and is easy to smudge for the perfect look. Love it!"

Katie J. (5/5)

Good Pencil

"I am used to using liquid or gel liners so they are a little more striking and stay on longer. However, for a healthy pencil without all the bad stuff, this works great. I like the color and it goes on smoothly."

Suzanne (4/5)

Glides on so easily!

"This eyeliner glides on super quickly and is so creamy. Love that it doesn’t have any harmful ingredients in it. The brown is a lovely natural look for eyeliner!"

Desiree D. (5/5)

Perfection!

"Genuinely happy to stumble upon this EWG verified pencil eyeliner! Couldn't be happier to replace what I had used for years! Clean beauty is such a self-care must!"

Susan S. (5/5)

Blends

"Love, it blends so well, but stays in place."

Monique T. (5/5)

Ok, doesn’t stay put

"Glides on so easily. Looks great, but it doesn’t stay put. I don’t wear a ton of eyeliner so it’s not a huge deal for me. I use the Crunci setting powder, but hasn’t helped. Still working on how to make it stay put."

Betsey V. (4/5)

Love it

"Very pleased!"

Elijah W. (5/5)

Great eyeliner. A safe ingredient

"Great eyeliner. A safe ingredient eyeliner that stays on throughout the day."

Stacy W. (5/5)

The ease the liner goes

"The ease the liner goes on and does not smear."

Dianne V. (5/5)

Amazed!!

"Oh my gosh it stays and doesn’t even run!! I love it!!!"

Mikayla S. (5/5)

Q&A

You may also like

BEST SELLER
EWG Verified
Jar of Crunchi cream with white lid on a white backgroundWhite cream or gel on a white background
BEST SELLER
EWG Verified
Daylight® Advanced Facial CreamDaylight® Advanced Facial Cream
EWG Verified
Clarilight® Facial Essence (Toner)Clarilight® Facial Essence (Toner)
BEST SELLER
EWG Verified
Smart Primer®Smart Primer®
Sale price $50.00
4.9
BEST SELLER
EWG Verified
Beautifully Flawless FoundationBeautifully Flawless Foundation
4.7
+